Looking for suggestions

Hi, I'm a big time splosh-er that has done chocolate syrup, whip cream, cherry pies, cherry pie filling, peanut butter and jelly, eggs, and creme filled dounts. I'm looking for the next best thing to try that I can get at a super market and do at my house. Also if anyone here is from Arizona, USA I am looking to do this with a partner so im me... Thanks for any advice!